Wondering whether to choose the Moonlight Starlight Dream or the Moonlight Starlight Sleepwell? This in-depth guide compares features, materials, safety certifications, and real-world benefits to help you pick the perfect Made-in-USA crib mattress.
Choosing the right crib mattress is one of the most important nursery decisions you’ll make. Moonlight (formerly Moonlight Slumber) is known for premium, Made in USA crib mattresses with thoughtful, baby-safe materials and smart construction. Two of their most popular models—Starlight Dream and Starlight Sleepwell—share a dual-stage design but differ in depth, cover, airflow, and cooling technology. Below, we break down exactly how they compare so you can buy with confidence.
Model Overviews
Moonlight Starlight Dream (5" Dual-Stage)
The Starlight Dream is Moonlight’s value-friendly best-seller. At 5 inches deep, it delivers a supportive dual-stage sleep surface:
- Infant side: Extra-firm comfort foam infused with plant oils for safer newborn sleep.
- Toddler side: Softer, plush comfort foam (also plant-oil infused) for growing kids.
- Cover: Hypoallergenic performance fabric that is antimicrobial and resistant to water, stains, and odors.
- Construction: SafeSewn™ seams, squared corners for a snug crib fit, lightweight for easy sheet changes.
- Safety: Woven fire barrier with no spray-on chemicals; GREENGUARD Gold certified for low emissions.
- Made in USA
Dimensions: 27.5" x 52" x 5"
Shop the Starlight Dream or View product information
Moonlight Starlight Sleepwell (6" Premium Dual-Stage)
The Starlight Sleepwell is the upgraded, premium option. At 6 inches deep, it enhances comfort and protection with advanced materials:
- Infant side: Eco-friendly, extra-firm foam for optimal early-months support.
- Toddler side: BabyCool™ temperature-regulating foam for a cooler, more comfortable sleep.
- Core: BreatheWell™ engineered airflow core to circulate air through the mattress.
- Cover & seams: Medical-grade deluxe knit cover with SafeSealed™ welded seams; waterproof, stain- and odor-resistant.
- Protection: Woven mineral-derived fire barrier (no chemical sprays); added resistance to dust mites and bed bugs.
- Made in USA
Dimensions: 27.5" x 52" x 6"
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Starlight Dream | Starlight Sleepwell |
|---|---|---|
| Depth | 5 inches | 6 inches |
| Design | Dual-stage (infant extra-firm / toddler plush) | Dual-stage (infant extra-firm / toddler BabyCool™ cooling foam) |
| Core / Airflow | Supportive foam core | BreatheWell™ airflow-engineered core |
| Cover & Seams | Performance fabric; SafeSewn™ seams | Medical-grade deluxe knit; SafeSealed™ welded seams |
| Moisture Protection | Water, stain & odor resistant | Waterproof; water, stain & odor resistant |
| Cooling | — | BabyCool™ temperature-regulating toddler side |
| Pest/Allergen Resistance | Antimicrobial, hypoallergenic cover | Added resistance to dust mites & bed bugs |
| Fire Barrier | Woven barrier; no spray-on FR chemicals | Mineral-derived woven barrier; no chemical sprays |
| Certification | GREENGUARD Gold | GREENGUARD Gold |
| Weight/Handling | Lightweight; easy sheet changes | Heftier premium build; still manageable |
| Best For | Great value & essentials | Premium comfort, cooling & protection |
Key Differences Explained
1) Depth & Feel
The Sleepwell’s extra inch (6" vs. 5") gives a plusher overall feel—especially noticeable on the toddler side—while maintaining a safely firm infant surface on both models.
2) Cooling & Airflow
If temperature regulation is a priority, the Sleepwell’s BabyCool™ toddler side and BreatheWell™ airflow core offer enhanced breathability and comfort compared with the Dream’s standard foam core.
3) Cover, Seams & Waterproofing
Both covers are durable and easy to clean. The Sleepwell upgrades to a medical-grade knit with SafeSealed™ welded seams and full waterproofing, creating a stronger barrier against moisture and messes.
4) Protection & Cleanliness
The Dream features a hypoallergenic, antimicrobial performance cover. The Sleepwell adds bed bug and dust mite resistance for families who want extra protection.
5) Budget Considerations
The Dream delivers outstanding value with dual-stage performance at a friendlier price point. The Sleepwell costs more but includes premium materials, cooling tech, and additional hygiene features.
Which Moonlight Mattress Should You Choose?
Choose the Starlight Dream if you want:
- An excellent, affordable dual-stage mattress that covers the essentials.
- A lightweight build for quick, easy sheet changes.
- GREENGUARD Gold certification and a no-spray woven fire barrier.
Choose the Starlight Sleepwell if you want:
- Premium comfort with BabyCool™ temperature regulation.
- Enhanced hygiene via SafeSealed™ welded seams and waterproof medical-grade cover.
- BreatheWell™ airflow core plus added dust mite & bed bug resistance.
Still unsure? Our product experts can walk you through both options and help with fit, care, and setup. Visit us at our Dublin, CA showroom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are both mattresses Made in the USA?
Yes. Both the Moonlight Starlight Dream and Starlight Sleepwell are proudly made in the USA with baby-safe materials.
Do both models have a dual-stage (2-sided) design?
Yes. Both offer an extra-firm infant side and a softer toddler side. The Sleepwell’s toddler side uses BabyCool™ foam for temperature regulation.
What’s the main comfort difference?
Depth and cooling. The Dream is 5" with plush toddler foam; the Sleepwell is 6" and adds BabyCool™ foam plus a BreatheWell™ airflow core for enhanced comfort.
Which cover is more protective?
Both are easy to clean. The Sleepwell upgrades to a medical-grade knit cover with SafeSealed™ welded seams and full waterproofing for added protection.
Will either mattress fit a standard full-size crib?
Yes. Both are designed for standard full-size cribs (approx. 27.5" x 52"). Always confirm your crib’s interior measurements and ensure a snug fit with no gaps.